Trophy Blend Scents is the only one I have decided warrants a second purchase....

I've tried both! Artificial/bottled liquid scents (the ones you buy that are out on the shelves in the open), the fresh liquid urines, and even a thin paste scent. None of them would keep over an off-season, and in the case of the artificial scents, they didn't seem to work all that well. Then I tried the Trophy Leaf, thinking it would be less messy, but they didn't seem to work either, and after a single off season, they mostly smelled of plastic.

With the TBS, it seems like they can't help but stop and investigate, and investigate calmly.

Like I said earlier, I had a decent (for me) buck come in last year that was moving at a fair clip. I think he got bumped by the squirrel hunter that was in the woods. He had to check out where I laid a scent line, and seemed to almost immediately calm down. If the zone hadn't enacted AR that season, he would have been on the ground. (Would have been legal if he hadn't been missing browtines). There were a number of similar stories last year, so I never shared. However, I think that the product being just as good a year later is worth saying something though.

Thank You,